Are All Weather Tires as Good as Winter Tires?
All weather is a real category with a real snow rating. It is also a compromise, and it is worth knowing exactly what you are trading away.
All weather is a genuine category, not marketing. It is also a compromise, and the honest version of this comparison is worth having before you decide.
What makes it a real category
All weather tires carry the three peak mountain snowflake, the same symbol as a dedicated winter tire. That means they passed the same standardised snow traction test.
That single fact separates them from all season tires, which carry only M+S and have passed no snow test at all. The names are unhelpfully similar and the gap between them is large.
Where all weather matches a winter tire
Light to moderate snow on treated roads. On plowed, salted city streets with a few centimetres down, a good all weather tire is close enough that most drivers would not notice.
Cold dry pavement. The compound stays more pliable in the cold than an all season, so braking and steering on a cold dry morning are clearly better than all season and reasonably close to winter.
Slush and cold rain. Good tread voids clear water and slush well.
Where a dedicated winter tire is clearly better
Ice. Not close. Winter compounds and siping are engineered for ice, and studded tires more so. If you regularly face glare ice, an all weather tire is a significant step down.
Deep and unplowed snow. A winter tire's deeper tread and more open blocks clear snow and keep biting. All weather tread is shallower by design, because it has to work in summer too, and it packs up sooner.
Severe cold. Below about minus 15, the gap widens. Winter compound is formulated for that range. All weather compound is making a compromise across a much wider temperature band.
Braking distance on packed snow. Independent testing consistently shows a meaningful gap, often several car lengths from highway speed.
What all weather costs you in summer
This is the side of the trade people forget.
Against a good all season tire in summer, an all weather tire:
- Wears faster, because the compound is softer
- Has slightly longer dry braking distances
- Is usually noisier
- Has marginally higher rolling resistance, so slightly more fuel
It is a compromise in both directions, which is what a year round tire has to be.
Who all weather genuinely suits
You drive in town, on plowed roads, and not far. The conditions where winter tires pull ahead are the conditions you rarely meet.
You have nowhere to keep a second set. Real constraint, honestly answered.
You drive very little. If you cover 8,000 km a year, the faster summer wear barely registers, and you avoid two changeovers.
You need something legal and capable and you are not going to book changeovers. An all weather tire you actually have on the car beats a winter tire sitting in a basement because the appointment never got made. That is a real scenario and all weather is the right answer to it.
Who should run dedicated winters
You drive rural roads, hills, or are out before the plow. The gap in deep snow is where safety lives.
Your commute includes untreated road. Ice is the condition where the difference is largest.
You cover significant distance. The faster summer wear of all weather starts to cost real money, and two sets each running half the year often work out similarly on total cost.
You want the best winter grip available. Then it is studded or studless winter, not a compromise.
The straight answer
All weather tires are better than all season tires in winter by a wide margin, and they are not as good as winter tires on ice and deep snow by a margin that matters.
For a New Brunswick winter, if you can run a dedicated winter set, do. If you genuinely cannot, all weather is a defensible choice and much better than leaving all seasons on.
Tell us where you drive and how far and we will tell you straight which one fits. We carry both.
Frequently asked questions
Do all weather tires have the snowflake symbol?
Genuine all weather tires do. That is what separates them from all season tires, which typically carry only M+S.
Are all weather tires good enough for a New Brunswick winter?
They are adequate for mostly plowed city driving. On deep snow, ice and unplowed rural roads a dedicated winter tire is clearly better.
Do all weather tires wear faster?
In summer, yes, compared to an all season. The softer compound that gives them winter capability wears quicker in heat.
Related
Book your visit at PitStop & Go
300 Wilsey Road #1, Fredericton, New Brunswick E3B 5J1 · (506) 248-6006